Pasta & Patchwork
  • Home
  • About P&P
  • Patterns
  • Recipes
  • Projects
  • Product Reviews

Crackers for Cloth IV - Reusable Nappy Comparison & Rating

3/9/2015

2 Comments

 
In the last installment of Crackers for Cloth, I crunched the numbers and came up with what I thought would be the ideal reusable nappy stash. Eventually we ended up with 25 nappies for our Bean, which we were happy with. Along the way we've put a good number of different nappies through their paces, so I thought it would be good to make a little comparison. 
Reusable diaper comparison & rating
Below I've rated six nappies by six different companies. These comparisons are of course based entirely on my own subjective opinion, but I hope it might help if you're thinking about which nappies to buy. 

Picture

Nappy: Bamboozle Stretch

Made by: TotsBots

Description: A bamboo nappy with velcro-style tabs, available in two sizes. Comes with a detachable booster. Needs a separate waterproof cover (such as Blueberry Coverall or Motherease Rikki).

Positives: Extremely absorbent and, in combination with a waterproof cover, totally bomb-proof. Easily lasts 4hrs. If you add extra absorbent padding (such as the Super Booster by Totsbots) this nappy will see you through 10-12 hours at night.

Negatives: Very bulky despite TotBots' claims to the contrary, and very slow to dry. More hassle for daycare providers to put on due this nappy needing a separate cover.
P&P Says: The best night-time nappy on the market


Nappy: Pop-in +bamboo V2

Made by: Close (formerly Close Parent)

Description: Two-part nappy which consists of a waterproof outer and two detachable bamboo inners. Fits from roughly from birth to potty (7-35 lbs/3.2-16 kg). Velcro-style tabs to close. Poppers on the front to adjust size.

Positives: Good absorbency. Elasticated gusset gives a snug fit, so containment is also good. Realistically fits a wide age range. Easy to put on. Fabulous prints.

Negatives: The V2 inners are not compatible with the V1 shells, though the V2 is slimmer as a result of the changes Close have made. Fiddly laundry tabs.
P&P Says: 
Excellent day-time nappy that will last a long time.
Picture
Picture



Nappy:
Charlie Banana One Size

Made by: Charlie Banana

Description: Pocket nappy consisting of a waterproof outer and two microfiber inners that are stuffed inside the outer. Fastened with poppers. Fits from roughly from birth to potty (6-35 lbs/3-16 kg). Size is adjusted using a bra strap-like system inside the gusset of the waterproof outer.

Positives: Very absorbent but also reasonably quick to dry. Realistically fits a wide age range. Looks great.

Negatives:  Bulky. Bra strap-like size adjustment system inside the nappy is fiddly to use.
P&P Says: 
Most absorbent day-time nappy on the market.


Nappy: Smartipants One Size

Made by: Smartipants

Description: Pocket nappy consisting of a waterproof outer and one removable inner that is stuffed inside the outer. Fits from roughly from birth to potty (7-35 lbs/3.2-16 kg). Fastened and adjusted in size with poppers.

Positives: Slim-looking, easy to stuff. No need to pull the inner out before washing as it comes out on its own. Fast-drying.

Negatives: Needs boosting or changing frequently if used on older babies. Comes up very short and so will realistically fit up to about 25 lbs (11.5 kg).
P&P Says: 
Easy-to-use, slim daytime nappy for younger babies.
Picture
Picture





Nappy:
Freetime All-in-One

Made by: Bumgenius

Description: One-piece nappy in which the absorbent inners are partially attached to the waterproof outer. Fastens with either aplix or poppers. Poppers on the front to adjust size. Fits from roughly from birth to potty (8-35 lbs/3.6-16 kg).

Positives: Very slim nappy that is still reasonably absorbent. Extremely fast-drying. Easy to use. 

Negatives: The sizing around the legs is generous so does not fit well on skinny minnies. Needs boosting or changing frequently if used on older babies/toddlers.
P&P Says: Slimmest-looking nappy on the market.



Nappy:
MioSolo All-in-One

Made by: Bambino Mio

Description: One-piece nappy in which the absorbent core is attached on one side to the waterproof cover and stuffed inside it, but can be pulled out to improve washing performance and drying time. Fits from roughly from birth to potty (7-35 lbs/3.2-16 kg). Velcro-style tabs to close. Poppers on the front to adjust size.

Positives: Good absorbency. Fast-drying. Comes up long, so will fit well even on an older/tall toddler.

Negatives: Very big on smaller babies, so would fit better from 12 lbs+ in reality.
P&P Says: Excellent day-time nappy for older babies & toddlers.
Picture

As for where to buy, if you're in the UK I can wholeheartedly recommend babipur, The Nappy Lady and Fill Your Pants*. All of these online retailers provide excellent service and often have good deals on**. If you're looking to buy used nappies, this facebook group is a great place to start.

If you've got your nappy stash all sorted but you're still wondering about the practicalities of using them, you might like these tips and tricks. 

*Disclosure: All opinions in this post are my own and links are not affiliated. No compensation or reward was provided in return for writing this post.

**A word about cheap deals. We are all for thrifty parenting here, and there is a UK-based online cloth nappy retailer (who shall remain nameless) who often has the lowest prices on the market. However, their service is no match for that of the companies I've mentioned, and in my opinion it is not worth saving a few pounds for the extra hassle of orders turning up late, incomplete, or not at all...

Come say hello: 
Pasta & Patchwork - Home

Picture
2 Comments
Amanda link
3/10/2015 07:24:54 am

Fantastic post! We were unlucky in that O was a super heavy wetter... He could outpee a pocket nappy with 3 bamboo boosters in within a couple of hours so we pretty much lived on little lamb bamboo fitted with an extra booster and motherland wraps... They would be soaked through within 2-3 hrs but the wrap worked a treat at keeping him dry. We could never manage nighttime as balancing extra boosting with comfort was a nightmare. We still had some pockets, especially towards the end, but they were certainly not as reliable for us. I still have all his nappies as I have yet to decide what to do with them...

Reply
Eline @ Pasta & Patchwork link
3/25/2015 04:37:10 am

Night time is definitely tricky, though we found disposables weren't any better and so we stuck with what just about worked! I still haven't dealt with the box, by the way...

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Hello! I'm Eline, and I've recently moved to a new corner of the internet: 
    www.emmyandlien.com/
    ​
    Do come and say hello!

    Read more:
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013


    Hookin on Hump Day
    Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.